Thankyou Seedjoe for replying.
Quote
seedjoe
Please, I am Jewish, by choice,
I am Jewish by blood.
Not the religion, the people.
My entire line of German relatives were wiped out - I do not use the word Nazi lightly.
Quote
seedjoe
my wife and young children are Jewish, I have stood on the ruins of the crematoria in Poland, know men with tattoos on their arms form death camps, friends who lost their entire families and have seen the "certainty" of the Nazi phenomena!
And you are displaying a certainty that a nazi officer would be proud of!
Quote
seedjoe
I am afraid I see a lot of that kind of certainty on these lists, by people who have never first hand been at an MKP event! The Nazis killed 6 million Jews and millions of others.
And where will MKP be in 10 years time? The Nazi party did not start out killing Jews..... Anyway, see my later point - I am not going to get dragged into this. This is not what I was suggesting.
Quote
seedjoe
It is obscene to compare the Nazi phenomenon to any program like MKP,
No its not, as MKP uses sciences developed by Nazi scientists, and Jung, a pro-nazi. That is my point - not the end result, but the method.
You do accept that there is a methodology/ideology at play here, don't you?
Quote
seedjoe
which has saved many marriages, lives form addiction to drugs and alcohol, helped men give up violent ways. I have had many letters over the years from wives thanking MKP; far outnumber those who have complained about it.
This is impossible to argue one way or another, MKP being a secret society. Let me explain this logic. The US army refuses to count enemy war dead. So they say they killed less in this gulf war than the last. Erm, how do they know?!
The same here - you cannot say if it does save marriges or not - no statistical evidence is collected! You are making a reality up that suits you. Please, lets stick to facts.
Quote
seedjoe
As to sleep deprivation: Fact; men are given at least 4-7 hours of sleep each of the two over nights they are there.
Food deprivation: Fact: men arrive after dinner on Friday men are fed light nourishing meals of fruit, granola, , juice, trail mix, etc throughout the training, good Jewish chicken soup on Saturday night and a feast on Sunday prepared by all the men present.
And to LEARN, you need a break of 15mins every 45 mins to maintain critical awareness.
4-7 hours sleep is NOT enough if you are being 'educated'.
Seedjoe - do you REALLY believe that is enough? Especially for the larger Americans!
Quote
seedjoe
The training is rigorous,
Another classic sign of mind-control.
Quote
seedjoe
but no more so than Outward bound, which my wife led for many years, or the Israeli army, which my wife was a member of.
Don't even start me on human rights abuses by and to the Israeli Army. These thugs shoot unarmed children (FACT- as supported by the UN), infact, Isreal has been breaking UN conditions for the past 30years or more. Another strong defense seedjoe - showing a total lack of understanding with the world you are in, or the methods you are playing with.
Quote
seedjoe
It is a rigorous training to prepare men to be rigorous with themselves.
And should a mentally disturbed person (and you have to be to WANT to go on this) be in that position?!
Quote
seedjoe
But the power flows to the men, and no one is ever hounded persecuted, or dissed for walking away if it does not serve them.
What power?
And how can you say that no one is EVER hounded or persecuted? That sounds like a classic denial!!! Nothing is all good or all bad.
Quote
seedjoe
Men occasionally leave the training, and men often do not engage in I groups, ongoing development work, etc.
How often? I would like stats please.
Quote
seedjoe
This is the worst managed cult I’ve ever seen! The Republican Party,
A point we can agree on, except the Republican are not a cult or a LGAT. But if it is a cult/LGAT - then MKP certainly is!!! Seedjoe - think of what you are saying before you type!
Quote
seedjoe
most Christian Churches I’ve seen,
Hmmmm, so how do you explain the diversity withing the broad theology/philosophy of Christianity? I must confess - we have far less fundamentilst christians in the UK - thankfully - may have something to do with the Mayflower - so where did all our religious wackos go?!?!
Quote
seedjoe
and most corporate cult-ures do a much better job of maintaining power, siphoning off money, and instilling their own belief into people than MKP. Even the Green Bay packers are a bigger cult than MKP (I happen to be a member of that cult myself.)
As I have said, MKP is a small (tiny) elitist little boys club. I do believe the organisers may have been refused Masonic entry, some of the beliefs cross so much.
But yes, until stumbling across LGATs and the Cults the US is having troubles with and this topic deserving my attention, I was very much against the corporate power (another bloody US import) that has ripped British culture to pieces. I still think corporations ARE the evil - has no-one noticed that a supposidly Christian country is the biggest capitalist country - but also the coutry with the largest debt!!!! I digress!
Quote
seedjoe
Look, what you are trying to accomplish is noble,
noble? Necessary
Quote
seedjoe
and there are certainly mistakes made in every organization- MKP is no exception.
Thank you for noting what we have already noted.
Quote
seedjoe
But you’ all are barking up the wrong tree.
Erm, I'm not barking up a tree. What do you mean by this metaphor?
Quote
seedjoe
And the publishing of MKP protocols is interesting, but like publishing a recipe book. The taste of the food does not live there. Even a bland description of a woman given birth would look weird if described by someone who didn’t understand what was happening (I’ve been at 6, so I know as much as a man can about it)
A reciepe doesnt describe coercion tactics and new-age psuedo-science. A reciepe doesn't pretend to give unhappy people therapy. How can an intelligent person make such a comparison?!
Quote
seedjoe
I also thought that one of the rules of this list was to refrain from personal attacks. Why am I being attacked personally (by at least one respondent accusing me of being a "wanna- be Native American")
Mate, that is NOT a personal attack! NEVER visit the UK - you'd leave crying - thats a personal attack?! We know nothing about you. I stand by what that respondent said - anyone who goes on this weekend is playing with traditions that are not theirs. (Ooooh - just like the Nazis!!!!!)
Quote
seedjoe
I don’t remember even mentioning native American ritual or culture,
You didn't have to - to defend MKP is to defend the cultural appropriation of another cultures beliefs and traditions. I'm British - we were great at doing that. I, for one, am very sorry what the Brits did in their colonial past - you Yanks had better get ready soon when your little empire falls.
Quote
seedjoe
and the ones that MKP uses have been sanctioned by Fool’s Crow of the Lakota nation.
Quote
seedjoe
I’m not into it myself- my Jewish path gives me all the spiritual guidance I need.
So if it does - why do you need to be a part of this little boys club?!!!!!!!
You contradict yourself - I've noticed this with all MKP people - they just twist things to be as you may want to hear things. Wierd. I have beliefs and stand by them, plain and simple.
Quote
seedjoe
I suppose I’ll be attacked for that now too.
Erm, you are a victim aren't you?! Hey, I know a great weekend you can go on - it costs $600 - payable to me. During the weekend - ohhhh, sorry, can't tell you.
Quote
seedjoe
Remember, the Talmud teaches that we do not see things as they are; we see them as we are. If see cults around every corner (it used to be Commies), everything will look like a cult to me.
Yep, the US has had hang-ups for years about these things - why import your social mess to us?! Not fair!
Quote
seedjoe
I leave you all with one question. Are Outward Bound, the US Army, the Green Bay packers, and most organized religions cults? If so why? If not, why not?
We are not discussing cults on this thread, if you had bothered to read the top of the page we are in the 'Large Group Awareness Training, "Human Potential" Seminars' section.
MKP is a LGAT - would love you to explain how it isn't.
That is different to an organisation that doesn't strip practiononers of dignity, sleep and food, such as outward bound. Never heard of these Green Bay packers, sorry. But yes, the US army is a cult led by one very sick man!!!! (I'm not serious about the US army being a cult, but your 'president' is very sick.