Quote
BearSong
i've tried to detach myself from this argument, but have to say a few more things. if you want to keep me in this conversation, i'm asking for respect . . . the contempt, personal attacks, and comparing me to a nazi etc does not warm me to participation.
You are always free to comment, it is welcome, as I have said.
I still see no personal attacks. And I have certainly not compared YOU to a nazi, but your organisation, I believe uses similar techniques, yes. Do not take that personally - I can't understand why you have.
Quote
BearSong
i stated in a previous post that i'll take your criticisms seriously, which i am/will. i'm hopeful that you'll take a sincere moment to consider whether there could be a grain of truth in what i have to say.
There is more than a grain of truth in what you have said, before this post and in this post. Doesn't mean I agree with your truth though. I seem to hold a different truth. And I do that in total respect to yours. I think I debate a little harder than you and a few others. Sorry, but I really do think we Brits use this language a little different - and I say that from doing political speech analysis.
Quote
BearSong
mkp takes extraordinary meas ... .... rks so well to help men get some freedom from what's not working FOR THEM.
MKP can be seen to do an amazing amount of good, yes. Of course. All LGAT's in some principle do good. Jung meant well, as did some others that have influenced these principles. But please, Bearsong, let me explain something. I have nothing against New Age beliefs, I have studied Buddhism for a few years now. I do not consider myself a buddhist though. What I believe is wrong with MKP is that I believe the 3 originators of this ideology (and it IS an ideology - I hope we agree there) simply appropriated various rituals (fair enough) but only to mask the Nuero-linguistic and est-based 'technologies'. So I am sitting on the fence. I do believe the 'intitian' is, in principle, great. I just think this is misguided. For one, it preaches a overtly sexist ideology that I am not comfortable with.
Quote
BearSong
mkp does some teaching about how to access, express, and contain feelings (which most men, at least in the u.s., are completely under-educated about) but does not try to get men to believe anything. instead to help them create the life THEY want.
also, there is very little that could be considered "native american" on the training.
Quote
BearSong
also, the name i'm using in this dialogue is part of my last name.
also, i am part native american as are a number of other men in mkp.
also, i've had the honor of dancing traditional native american dances for many years (in which i've gone without food or water for 3-4 days at a time). the fasting part of initiation is ancient and it's done with respect. the food situation on the mkp weekend is done respectfully as well, is a choice, and doesn't even come close to an actual fast. It’s an opportunity to eat healthy for 48hrs and not over eat as a self-medication so there is a chance for some healing.
Again, I have no issue here - if only you were this open initially friend. We can build a dialogue now I believe. At the risk of repeating previous posts, each different 'cell' will of course interpret the protocols and priniciple differently. I do not accuse MKP of blanket this or that, except in an ideological and methodological sense.
I must say that I do not believe that enough information is given before people go on this weekend - perhaps you yourself tell more than is on the leaflet, and if you do, I respect that. It is the potential damage that LGATs can do that freaks me out - a few of my friends lost their minds through choice - on drugs. Its all the same.
Quote
BearSong
i suspect that i could address every point you make and there will be an infinate amount of other uninformed assumptions you'll make. so, it seems futile here.
I wish you would address each issue, and I hope that you won't project your own assumptions of our assumptions of you onto us for much longer - thats very negative Bearsong. I really am sorry we got off on the foot we did - Everyone on this board has been effected by this group - positively or negatively - both with TRUTH. You know I have read all your literature, do you think I am lying in that?
Quote
BearSong
maybe you're wrong (can you even imagine the possibility?).
Bearsong, to believe I may be wrong is one of the Principles of My Order!
Quote
BearSong
maybe mkp is the healthiest (although imperfect) and couragous group out there trying to change the world (which is at war in so many ways, as i'm sure you can see . . . and at war mostly because folks are angry, hurt, unconscious and see everybody else as their enemy).
But maybe its not? Maybe it is a ruse? Maybe it is a deception such as the one GWB has pulled over the world?
Quote
BearSong
this dialogue will not affect mkp growth in any noticable way.
It will not, but it will allow those who have been affected negatively a space to bond and have a community.
Quote
BearSong
but i'm sad that a few men will read the protocol, your uninformed comments, misinterpret the spirit of the work (as you have) and will have their experience lessened or corrupted. i'm confident that the imagined and fantasized abuses that were posted here will be disregarded by anyone that is not “mind-controlled” by this site.
I'm pleased they will have a more informed and free choice. Certainly the questionnaire shows that they are targeting those who could be seen to be 'depressed'.
Quote
BearSong
AGAIN, FOR THE BENIFIT OF ANYONE WHO HAS NOT BEEN CORRUPTED BY THIS CULT OF FOLKS WHO ARE SPENDING THEIR LIFE LOOKING FOR CULTS, THE SEXUAL ALLEGATIONS AND OTHER ACCUSATIONS OF ABUSE BY MKP ARE FALSE AND ARE COMPLETELY COUNTER TO THE CARING, MATURE ATMOSPHERE AT THESE WEEKENDS.
UN declaration of human rights. NO arguments here.
I again quote Voltaire! "I disagree with everything you are saying, but I defend your right to say it with my life"
Quote
BearSong
i'd like to let you know that your suggestion that i'll "need support" is received as a caring comment, but tells me we are on different planets of reality. i'll consider your points but, mkp is one of many areas of support i have in my life. i'll be moving more deeply into that work and lovingly inviting others as well.
I do care Bearsong - why don't you trust me there? My mistrust in the organisation doesn't mean a mistrust in you. Your original post is as if a different person wrote it - reread it. Good change.
Quote
BearSong
"There is a principle which is a bar against all information, which is proof against all arguments and which cannot fail to keep a man in everlasting ignorance - that principle is contempt prior to investigation."
Herbert Spencer
It is investigation that has brought about our differing opinions BearSong. I hope you take the time and read some threads on this forum about Landmark especially.
For example - Bearsong - are you aware that you have signed ALL legal rights away? Look at a post I wrote above, and one on the landmark page I found after that.
I do hope that, whilst we may disagree, we can know 'look each other in the eye'.