Re: Cryonics, Cult Movement or Ligit Science???
Posted by:
SteveHarrisMD
()
Date: March 12, 2010 12:42PM
Alcor's "Medical Director" Dr. Steve Harris, California Medical License #G 52760 recently admits to utilizing Propofol on their "members." He so arrogantly quotes:
"A conservative dose of propofol is 140 mg, you say. We give 200 mg. There you are. If there are any signs of awareness later, such as eyelid movement or even shivering (not a sign of awareness but certainly a sign of CNS activity), another equal dose is held in reserve. This is probably not likely to be necessary, given the fact that the patient is being cooled and not normally perfused for the duration of action of a single induction dose of propofol (at least 15 minutes and probably more)."
This is incredible that Harris, a physician, would openly admit to this online. Go to this link [www.network54.com] to see Harris's quote, before it is removed.
So if cryonics patients are already dead, why is Harris and cryonics officials concerned about "awareness", shivering and eyelid movement to the point that they have a dose of Propofol ready to inject? This is crazy!
Melody Maxim, who consistantly calls Harris out is shocked that he would open admit to utilizing Propofol. See Melody's post at: [www.network54.com]...
==============
COMMENT:
Ms. Maxim is hardly shocked , as years ago she worked for a cryonics company where it was her job to inventory medical kits which stocked propofol for use in cryonics patients.
As explained on the other site, the primary purpose of propofol in cryonics is as a brain protective agent (a well-known property of the substance). However, since cryonics members have worried that there is a chance that chest compression and circulation of blood to the brain will cause some return of consciousness (this has been reported in resuscitation cases, during cardiac arrest), propofol also insures that a still-living brain does not regain the sort of awareness that causes reports of near-death-experiences. I personally have never seen any sign of this in cryonics, but the resuscitation literature suggests that it is possible.
How can a person who is legally dead, in cardiac arrest, have a brain that is still alive? That is the routine when patients are pronounced legally dead on the basis of cardiopulmonary arrest (as happens in hospices and many other situations). And NOT only in cryonics. This happens to everyone who dies while being medically monitored, who is pronounced promptly. It requires minutes to hours for the brain to “die” after that point (we really don’t know how long), since biological death is not the same as legal death. The whole point of cryonics and organ donation is that cells, tissues, and organs remain alive for a time after the standard medico-legal system has given up (legal death). In the average person, people simply stand around after that point, while the tissues and cells slowly die. In cryonics, by contrast, something is being done about it.
Pronouncement of legal death in cryonics is not done by a cryonics person, but by the doctor or nurse working for the hospice, or by a paramedic. These people have no vested interest in cryonics, and they’re the ones who make the decision that the person is in cardiac arrest and beyond meaningful help from standard medicine. That is what “legally dead” means; it’s a social definition of a social relationship, like being legally divorced. It’s not meant to be perfectly scientific, in part since it depends a lot on personal choice, and advanced directives from patients and family.
What happens after legal death in cryonics, is an experimental race to save brain cells and information. Anyone who is shocked by this experiment is perfectly free to be part of the control group, where the cells and information are allowed to disappear. Personally, I’ve opted for the experimental group, since the controls are certainly doing poorly, by any standard.
Steve Harris, MD