'create an environment (e.g. on an island) which is as little like punishment as possible, but which still keeps them away from mainstream society/children.'What strikes me about the above statement is how similar it is to Davejc's lifetime efforts to create an environment which is as little like punishment as possible but which keeps his members away from mainstream society and children.
Mainstream society is struggling to come up with appropriate ways of dealing with paedophiles, given that they are held to be incurable due to the early wrong wiring in their brains. Locking them up is seen as ineffective as a means of cure, or even a means of delivering a 'short, sharp, shock' which is often effective in helping offenders to rethink their progress in life.
Prisoners incarcerated together form a society in microcosm, with the more powerful routinely preying on the weaker, with none of the cultural customs and practices of mainstream society which give some measure of protection to the weaker and encourages protection by the more powerful.
Our cultural customs, practices and laws might be irksome at times but they are all we have to protect us from falling back into rampant barbarism.
There is a great cautionary novel 'Lord of the Flies' which examines the behaviour of a group of young, well-educated schoolboys marooned on an island and charts their fast descent into such barbarism.
[
en.wikipedia.org]
'Lord of the Flies is a novel by Nobel Prize-winning author William Golding. It is about a group of British schoolboys stuck on a deserted island who try to govern themselves, with disastrous results. Its stances on the already controversial subjects of human nature and individual welfare versus the common good earned it position 68 on the American Library Association’s list of the 100 most frequently challenged books of 1990–1999.'