Re: Chris Butler, Jagad Guru, Science of Identity
Posted by:
RUN_FOREST_RUN
()
Date: March 14, 2025 01:45AM
The Case That Doesn’t Add Up: Was Papalii Sia Figiel Framed for the Murder of Caroline Sinavaiana-Gabbard?
The brutal murder of Caroline Sinavaiana-Gabbard—a poet, scholar, and outspoken critic of her niece Tulsi Gabbard—was one of the most violent and improbable crimes in recent history. Nine months later, the case remains shrouded in silence, missing evidence, and unanswered questions.
The official narrative suggests that Papalii Sia Figiel, a respected novelist and literary mentee of the victim, suddenly snapped, brutally stabbing and beating her with a hammer after an argument. But there is no logical or historical basis for this explanation. In reality, every available detail suggests a different, more disturbing possibility:
A Theory That Actually Makes Sense
Given the improbable nature of the crime, the lack of clear motive, and Figiel's uncharacteristic behavior after the incident, the most plausible alternative explanation is that Figiel was drugged, set up, and used as a scapegoat for a premeditated murder.
1. Figiel May Have Been Drugged or Coerced
- Figiel had no history of violence—it is highly unlikely that she suddenly resorted to a graphic, overkill murder of a longtime mentor.
- Drugs like Scopolamine, Benzodiazepines, or Ketamine could have caused blackouts, compliance, or post-event amnesia—consistent with her dazed behavior after the crime.
- There are no toxicology reports publicly available—a glaring omission.
2. Her Post-Crime Actions Suggest Shock, Not Guilt
- Instead of fleeing, covering up the crime, or even attempting to justify it, Figiel went to a friend’s house and then turned herself in.
- This is not the behavior of a cold-blooded killer but someone who doesn’t understand what just happened.
- Her vague confession ("the devil made me do it") could be a shock-induced attempt to explain a reality she couldn’t process—or a planted narrative.
3. The Crime Was Overkill and Uncharacteristic
- The brutality of the attack—stabbings + blunt force trauma—suggests rage, not a simple dispute gone wrong.
- If this were a sudden escalation, a single lethal wound would have sufficed. Instead, the excessive violence feels more like a symbolic or ritualistic act.
- Who benefits from Sinavaiana-Gabbard’s violent and publicized death?
4. The Timing Was Too Convenient
- Caroline Sinavaiana-Gabbard was one of the few people who had intellectual credibility to challenge Tulsi Gabbard.
- Within months of her death, Tulsi made a strategic political shift, aligning with Trump’s MAGA coalition and gaining national security clearance.
- With Sinavaiana-Gabbard silenced, there was no one left within the family with enough influence to expose Tulsi’s connections to the Science of Identity Foundation (SIF).
5. The Legal and Media Silence is Suspicious
- High-profile cases usually have regular trial updates, forensic reports, and media analysis—yet this one has disappeared from public discourse.
- No detailed forensic sequence of injuries (what came first—blunt force trauma or stabbings?).
- No witness testimonies released.
- No final autopsy report accessible.
If this was a random act of violence, why is so much crucial information missing? Why is no one pressing for real answers?
The Gabbard Factor & The Cult Connection
Tulsi Gabbard’s entrenched involvement with the Science of Identity Foundation (SIF)—a secretive and politically connected cult—adds another layer of potential motive to this case.
- SIF has been accused of espionage-like tactics, character assassinations, and political maneuvering to protect its own.
- Gabbard’s rise in intelligence circles after this incident suggests a powerful network protecting her.
- If this murder was orchestrated to eliminate an inconvenient critic, SIF loyalists within Tulsi’s orbit could have been involved.
This is not an accusation, but the lack of investigation into external involvement in the crime is itself suspicious.
---
Final Thoughts
- If Figiel was drugged, she may have woken up confused, guilty, and traumatized in a crime scene she had no memory of.
- The real perpetrators may have used her as a scapegoat, ensuring that any investigation ended with her guilty plea—and no further inquiries were made.
- With no toxicology report, no forensic sequence, and no clear legal resolution, this remains one of the most suspicious unresolved cases involving a political figure in recent history.
Until there is a real investigation into alternative explanations, this case will stand as a dark stain on the credibility of both the Samoan legal system and the U.S. intelligence community that Gabbard is now a part of.
---
A Poetic Epitaph for the Truth
We close with words from both women—one, the murdered critic, and the other, the accused killer—both of whom, in their own ways, understood the cost of silence, power, and loss.
Caroline Sinavaiana-Gabbard on Tulsi Gabbard’s Political Ambitions
"Expedience has no principle, only its own hunger for power."
A warning, perhaps, that those who seek power without restraint will discard even family, even truth, to reach their goal.
Papalii Sia Figiel on Violence & Suppression
"There are many ways to be silenced. The sharpest knives leave no blood, only absence."
A chilling reflection on the cost of erasing voices—and what remains when the world chooses to forget.
Until the truth of this case is uncovered, we are left with nothing but absence—and questions.
RUN