Miracle of Love
Date: August 13, 2004 02:27AM
Defending an Illusory Cure--Speculations
*These are hunches. See if they fit your situation.
When people explode and go ballistic because you'r telling them painful information about their leader, what they may be doing is defending their sense that they've been healed by the leader. They feel better, but are unaware that their sense of well being did not result from resolving their problems but by suppressing their problems.
In technical terms they are defending the positive transferance they've formed to their leader. Without that positive transferance, they risk being ambushed by all the depression and anxiety they supressed by getting blissed out in the leader's group.
A therapist uses positive transferance to support authentic growth and autonomy. A needy leader exploits positive transferance to keep you dependant.
A genuine psychotherapist gets his or her needs met outside the therapy room, not from patients. A real therapist accepts both your positive transferance and negative transferance--which means you can admire that therapist and also get mad at the person. This helps you become conscious in relation to the emotions in that transferance, helps you understand unsolved problems that orginated from your early development. Gradually you get more adult and less dependant on the therapist.
Eventually you graduate and leave because the therapist has taught you to parent yourself.
But a needy leader relies on devotees for narcissistic affirmation. A leader of this kind wants only idealizing transferance and will refuse to tolerate any kind of negative, painful emotion. A leader of this kind lacks the maturity needed to teach people the skills needed to become independent in relation to the leader.
That is why groups like this censor 'negativity' seem gooey sweet all the time, and why so often, a member is the designated scapegoat to carry all the 'bad stuff' that the leader refuses to face.
In this set up, you may be all blissed out, but this may be at the cost of suppressing your full range of emotion, and you need lots of energy to maintain this self-censorship.
So you get hooked on the leader and environment that maintain this artificial high and you never leave.
You feel like you've been healed, but you have NOT worked through your suffering. You've merely suppressed it. Its just like becoming a dope addict with the group and its leader as the pusher.
Through the group/leaders monopoly on positive transferance, these people have disabled some or part of their adult function, and have regressed to blissful childhood. They are feeling blissful because their emotions have been re-arranged and manipulated to suppress life long patterns of anxiety and depression. Anything that disrupts thier idealizing transferance to the cult leader will take the lid off the suffering they suppressed and that unfinished business will return to haunt them.
Thats why people are so terrified of being kicked out--or being told the truth--their suppressed suffering hangs over them and they dont want it to come back.
A group leader of this kind may give relief, but the relief is suppression of one's suffering, not resolution of it. The devotees have not integrated their suffering, so [i:16775c1d2d]the bliss they feel is a bliss that has to be defended[/i:16775c1d2d], a bliss that is a high maintainance state that requires an increasingly high maintainance lifestyle--and more and more devotees to provide reassurance that its all for real when it isnt.
Bliss that embraces your full humanity, including your suffering--that requires no defence. Its an embrace of reality.
Bliss that requires exaltation of only part of your humanity and rejects the rest of who you are--that suppresses reality and requires an increasing expenditure of energy, time, money and constriction of emotion. This is the bliss that has to be defended through denial of the truth.
Genuine healing doesnt require all these props.
When people's illusions about a charismatic leader are threatened, their suppressed suffering threatens to return, along with the trauma of discovering they've been exploited. This is terrifying.
To defend their illusions (supported by lies they've been given) about the group and leader is to defend themselves, to defend their own (illusory but intense) experiences of relief.
To face the truth means the prospect of existential horror.