Quote
Eric_le_roi
That's a very strange attitude. You think every work of fiction is based on personal experience? Do you think Melville spent a lot of time hunting whales? Shakespeare is supposed to have never left England, but he still wrote convincingly about Europe and European culture.
I think you are narrow minded and lack an imagination. But thank you for your comments.
You apparently completely misunderstood what I said. I did not say that every book character has to be solely based on a writer's experience. But in my experience (and I have friends who are professional writers) there is usually something that the author puts into the character that comes from personal experience, or something about that character that reflects something the author is drawn to. Melville may not have hunted whales, but he lived in a maritime community (on Long Island) and no doubt had a great deal of interest in all things nautical including whales. He may not have had the exact same experiences as Ishmael, but there was something of himself in it.
I'm not saying that you have to be in a cult to write about someone in a cult, but I am saying that you need to understand the thoughts and feelings behind someone like that. The fact that you are posting on a Cult Education Forum (a place where people come to learn about the negative and destructive aspects of cults) proves my point exactly: You are looking at this character from an unsympathetic point of view. If you really wanted to create a believable character, you would go to a forum for people who are CURRENTLY in cults, not people who have left them.