Re: Gestalt Therapy Counseling
Date: August 30, 2012 10:26PM
I just wanted to add to this as I too have had bad experiences with gestalt. I've done quite a bit of research into its roots and I would agree that it is the psychotherapeutic arm of the encounter movements of the 60s. The founder of gestalt therapy, Fritz Perls, was a strange individual. His 'Gloria' counselling sessions are still used as examples of therapy in training institutions. Hopefully, they will be used as examples of bad therapy as in my opinion they demonstrate how a therapist should NOT behave. Gestalt therapy did indeed become very cult-like as Perls became enamoured with large group work. He was very much the guru, demonstrating his counselling techniques in from of large audiences in new age places like Esalin.
My experiences with a gestalt therapist lead me to believe that (at least some) disciples of that school of therapy are still adopting a Fritz Perl's style of counselling: abrasive, manipulative with heavy use of 'mind control' type techniques which keep the client off-balance and confused. The confusion techniques are not therapeutic; on the contrary they serve to further undermine and derail the client. This was certainly my experience with gestalt therapy and it was with a huge sense of relief that I quit therapy.
I think that any type of therapy has the potential to be somewhat 'cult like' especially if the therapist is setting him or her self up as the all-knowing authority figure rather than adopting a facilitator role. I think the thereapist I saw was keen to establish herself as an authority figure who I would end up becoming dependent on. By withholding what I was looking for (kindness, thoughfulness, mutual respect, being listened to) she was effectively trying to manipulate my emotions so that I would get increasingly frustrated and revert to a child-like state. Essentially behaving as a dysfunctional parent would.
Thankfully, I saw through her games and quit before real harm had occurred. However, it is worrying that she (and others like her) are out there practising with the full support of professional accrediting bodies.