Thank you M&M for a balanced perspective based on experience. Please, if you care to, share why you decided to leave.

I see so many simularities happening with Turning Point that have already taken place here at Radiant Life Church with Tony Cunningham, Turning Point is about 3 years behind what has happened at RLc. I would caution you all to evaluate the claim that Mike is an apostle? who made the prophisy?
also Mike needs to be honest with the church because the direction that Tony is trying to move into is setting up there own church denomination with Tony at the top.

I watched the videos and they are ghastly evident of another man there with enormous ego and whole chritian televangelist put on. I would run fast. The pictures and videos are almost identical to the young crowd in SOMA sacramento. I wonder how many of their family relationships are strained as evidenced by one students myspace comments below

"SOMA and stuff

I feel like God is placing a distinct call on my life to go to SOMA.

I talked to Megan Minnick, and even though I read the book of Mark, somehow I missed the part about how Jesus' family thought he was crazy. That makes me feel a lot better about how my family is going to treat me when I drop the bomb that college is on hold for now and I will in all likelihood be going to SOMA next year, moving out, and living in the dorms.

I tried the college thing...and I find that my spiritual eyes interfere with my homework. It shouldn't be that way. Like when I'm reading my Interpersonal Communication textbook and it keeps mentioning over and over about how we define ourselves by communication with other people and by comparing ourselves to them. While I know this is true, all I want to do is scream "My identity is in Christ!"

Or in Biology when we talk about evolution, I've only got apologetics on my mind.

Every week, I keep getting rocked by the Holy Spirit; and then I think, "This is onlt the beginning!" There's still some deep heart work that needs to be done that I don't even know about.

So pray for me...pray that God make's a way for me, that the persecution of my family does not shake my faith, and pray for healing for this pesky epilepsy. Health insurance would be a lot less of a deal if I didn't have so many health problems...


It is sad that this person believes that SOMA is going to take them to more godly heights. Diminishes the power of the Bible and Gospel. I wonder how many more families even outside of Sacramento are being destroyed because of a blind loyalty to a church or SOMA. You can experience great lifechange without the crutch and spiritual manipulation of SOMA. I am praying not only for this persons soul but for her health as it does appear she is very vulnerable and looking for longing and acceptance through SOMA at the possible expense of her family.

this is the response from a friend:

and even if your family does not approve of you it's up to you to make yourself happy and if it means following your heart through God then do so hun!!!! : ) good luck and just remember I will always be proud of you <3


This all sounds so familiar. Driven away from the foundation of family and towards the destruction of cult like practices. When will the family be promoted and encouraged. I guess it is happenning outside of Sacramento also.

I found this snippet in a paper entitled "Authoritarian Church Leadership and the Individual Freedom of Church Members". The entire article can be found at the following web site: [www.cultwatch.com]

7.9 Diotrephes The Dictator: An Example To Avoid

“I wrote to the church, but Diotrephes, who loves to be first, will have nothing to do with us. So if I come, I will call attention to what he is doing, gossiping maliciously about us. Not satisfied with that, he refuses to welcome the brothers. He also stops those who want to do so and puts them out of the church. Dear friend, do not imitate what is evil but what is good.” (3 John: 9-11a)

The words “I wrote” refers to a previous letter which has been lost. This lost letter probably contained instructions from John that Diotrephes ignored. Diotrephes was a man of influence and authority in the church who opposed the apostle John. His position is not clear but it was an important one. He was a domineering man who objected to the hospitality that Gaius had given to traveling evangelists who had John’s approval. He was more interested in advancing his own position than in furthering the work of God.

Diotrephes was motivated by pride and selfish ambition. “Loves to be first” (NIV) or “wants to be head of everything” (Philipps) or “enjoys being their leader” (NEB) is all one word in Greek, “philoproteuo”, Strong’s #5383. It occurs only here in the NT. Thayer describe it as “fond of being first, striving after the first place, to aspire after pre-eminence.”[29] Arndt and Gingrich define it as “wish to be first, like to be leader.”[30] The statement "loves to be first" probably indicates personal rivalry and a puffed up and domineering ego. Instead of giving the pre-eminence to the Lord Jesus Christ, he claimed it for himself. He also spread malicious gossip against John and he intolerantly rejected those who disagreed with him.

Every church needs to be wary of the religious dictator especially if that leader claims special authority or rights of seniority over the congregation, by virtue of his being one of the founders of the church. Often independent Pentecostal churches suffer from this abuse of spiritual authority. Every church needs a system of “checks and balances” to avoid this situation. All church leaders should be careful not to follow this bad example but model themselves on Christ. The genuine spiritual leader is not a dictator but a humble servant or slave like Jesus Himself (Philippians 2:7).

It is the responsibility of all church members to pray faithfully for their leaders and their families.




Copyright Notice
This document is Copyright 2002 by Cultwatch Inc. You may print this document on the condition the complete document is printed, including this text; and no changes are made to the document. Copies of this document maybe given away, but not for commercial gain. In fact we strongly suggest you print this document and send it to your Pastor. From your web site you may only link to this document. If you seek any permissions different from these please contact the Cultwatch Web Master.

People Who Live In Glass Houses Should Not Throw Stones

My reply to M&M's posting is "I very much agree with pretty much all you said"... I used to got to Turning Point and it still holds a very warm place in the hearts of my wife and I. And, at the risk of revealing who we are, we went to SOMA in Sacramento in its second year of existence. I have witnessed the workings of both churches. 90% of what is taught and how things are done, is wonderful and full of life. It's the other 10% that taints.

Thank you Godisfaithful. You post is most welcomed.

If we take truth and mix in 10% of untruth we end up with...untruth.

If I understood you correctly you are agreeing with M&Ms conclusion that over a period of time Turning Point has become authoritarian? And that Apostle Mike has positioned himself not as an authoritarian leader?

I do not wish to attribute words to you so I am asking that you clarify.

Thanks

Quote
GodisFaithful
My reply to M&M's posting is "I very much agree with pretty much all you said"... I used to got to Turning Point and it still holds a very warm place in the hearts of my wife and I. And, at the risk of revealing who we are, we went to SOMA in Sacramento in its second year of existence. I have witnessed the workings of both churches. 90% of what is taught and how things are done, is wonderful and full of life. It's the other 10% that taints.

I think you would get strong disagreement on here about your percentages. I personally have seen it the other way around, about 90% jacked up and 10 okay. I am glad you had a good edxperience but know that there are literally hundreds of people who have manipulated. It is not a healthy church and i am guessing you are one of the clique having gone to soma. I do thank you for sharing.

I’m going to address something here that is a common pattern that I have been seeing with Turning Point and Radiant Life and now Radiant Life Church of West Sacramento and Life Change Church in Coos Bay Oregon. They are apparently hiding something because they will not share or talk about who they are in relationship with and what that looks like. Its like catching the preacher in bed with someone other than his wife and the leadership is hiding the truth because they don’t want to pet the cat back wards or rock the boat. Now I say that to point out the absurdity that we all are seeing! When asking specific questions to the leadership of these churches they are being evasive or flat out ignoring the questions. I would encourage everyone to start calling these churches and asking them what are they teaching and who are they in bed with!

If these churches are remotely connected with Tony, then how is the congregation of that church going to know that they can trust there leadership?

How can they say that they can pick and choose the teachings from Tony, when they embrace the man himself and recognize him as some kind of apostle?

No matter how much connecting they have with Tony his DNA is being passed on. Like a bee pollinating a flower, the DNA carried by that bee is complete in just one landing. If you have a hard time understanding that last analogy Private Message me and I’ll explain the Birds and the Bees to you. (lol)

God Gives us these example from nature to help remind us that His Love and Grace are not complicated or hard to obtain. That our trusting Him is where life begins and our relationship with God grows.

I believe Church leadership needs to be accountable to the flock they are tending to!

When I receive an email back from church leaders and there is a blatant lie stating that they are NOT IN ANY WAY AFFILIATED WITH TONY CUNNINGHAM OR RADIANT LIFE CHURCH of SACRAMENTO the Red lights go off in my head and I have to start asking some hard questions. I would also encourage you to start asking questions of the leadership at your church then listen to your heart. I can not tell you how many times I got caught up in the emotions of RLc that my ears did not hear what Gods spirit was saying to my heart.

This teaching from Tony Cunningham has become a CANCER to the body Christ at Radiant Life Church in Sacramento. It has spread to Katy Texas, Laguna California, Marysville Washington and Coos Bay Oregon. Fortunately this Cancer has been renounced in Laguna California and we think Katy Texas.

Be on your guard test everything that is being said and taught including 5 Fold Ministry, Heart of David, Strategic Advance and Intense Discipleship Training. Test the teachings like Spiritual Parenting and see if they line up with the basic 10 commandments for example does Spiritual Parenting line up with the 5th Commandment? “You shall not dishonor your parents.” Or You shall not covet your neighbor's wife (daughter). Hmm....TONY CONTINUES TO HAVE EMOTIONAL AFFAIRS WITH HIS “SPIRITUAL DAUGHTERS and the Sycophant elders just sit back and let it happen. Or they too embrace this teaching and are engaging into these kinds of relationships.

Again be on your guard and test all the teachings from Tony Cunningham!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

This from christian-faith . com

True And False Apostles
Paul, an apostle of Jesus Christ by the will of God, and Timothy our brother. (1:1)

Paul is writing with tremendous spiritual authority. He is writing as an 'apostle', literally, 'a sent one' of Jesus Christ. Jesus Christ actually sent Paul out by divine revelation. Paul has learned to know the voice of the Lord, and the Lord has entrusted Paul with a lot of responsibilty. Paul is not an apostle because he wanted to be, but because God chose him to be. It was the will of God. Its just like what Jesus said to his 11 apostles in John 15:16 "You did not choose me, but I chose you and appointed you that you should go and bear fruit, and that your fruit should remain."

Are there apostles today?
Today there are no more apostles in the class of Paul or the twelve - Scripture writing apostles. There are still apostles of the class mentioned in Ephesians 4:11, which are given, the Bible says, UNTIL we all come to "the unity of the faith, the knowledge of the Son of God, to a perfect man, to the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ". No one could seriously claim we have arrived to this place yet as the Universal church, so logic compels us to acknowledge that Christ is still giving such apostles. The question is: does the church receive them? We should not limit our vision of what Christ can form in a man. An apostle is trained and equipped to function to some extent in all of the five-fold ministry gifts, but not with the same degree of specialisation. An apostle of Jesus Christ must be able to go into new areas, do the work of an evangelist, pastor and teach the people, and raise up a prophetic generation of intecessors and leaders who will storm heaven and plunder hell for the glory of God. An apostle should be experienced in delivering the spiritual gifts mentioned in 1 Corinthians 12 to people as the Lord leads. There should be outstanding miracles, signs and wonders and a humility and meekness which reflects the image of Christ, not the image of a big-time corporate CEO. An apostle knows how to prosper and how to get along with humble means. An apostle is a man of outstanding endurance and patience, who can rejoice in the midst of hardship.

Such apostles obviously do exist today, but probably don't care if people think they are apostles or not. They might prefer to be called "Brother" rather than "Pastor" or some such title. What is important is the genuineness of the calling, and the faithfulness to be obedient to it and in the years of preparation and service that lead up to it.

But even these apostles, who cannot write Scripture, or speak with the authority as one such as Paul, can only be true apostles if they were chosen by the Lord to be apostles. The Lord does not choose everyone for this kind of role. There are many different callings and roles. But the church needs true apostles who will do apostolic work in founding many new churches in previously unreached areas. What a desperate need exists for true apostolic ministry today! Look at a map of the world and consider how many towns and villages have little credible witness of the reality of Jesus Christ. God's plan is to send apostles in, or raise them up from within the local churches of these countries. May we understand the need for this, and align ourselves with the purposes of God for this generation!

In addition to having personal relationship and communication with Jesus Christ, an apostle, to function as such, must be a mature believer in Jesus Christ. It takes years of varied ministry experience to function as a true apostle. An apostle should be one who has learned to abide in Jesus Christ through thick and thin, who is not afraid to die either physically or soulishly. In his quest for the glory of God to be revealed and God to be honored, the apostle must take a fixed attitude of embracing personal suffering as required so the life of Jesus can be revealed and imparted to others (2 Corinthians 4:10,11). While some younger apostles may be somewhat prideful still at times, there is a way the Lord works to eliminate that characteristic to produce true meekness, brokenness and gentleness - in short, the genuine fruit of the Holy Spirit.

Apostolic Ministry and Money
Apostolic ministries usually have an outstanding call to the ministry, but this does not guarantee that they will be exempt from working for a living. Even though Paul had seen the Lord personally, he himself worked making tents, and so supplied not only himself but also his team with the material resources necessary to carry on the ministry. Paul said to the Ephesian elders, "I have coveted no one's silver or gold or apparel. Yes, you yourselves know that these hands have provided for my necessities, and for those who were with me. I have shown you in every way, by laboring like this, that you must support the weak. And remember the words of the Lord Jesus, that He said, 'It is more blessed to give than to receive.' " (Acts 20:33-35). Other apostles apparently had the right to refrain from working "Or is it only Barnabas and I who have no right to refrain from working?" (1 Corinthians 9:6) but Paul did not use this right so that he could have an extra reward from the Lord. Paul was happy to enter into financial partnership with churches, but it seems like only the Philippian church helped Paul himself financially - at least at the time of writing of the letter to the Philippians. We see this in Philippians 4:10-19. Paul knew that those who invested material resources towards his ministry would be abundantly supplied by God. Many try to claim the promise of abundant provision without investing in missions or in ministries like Paul's.

The reality remains that many genuine apostolic ministries and evangelists which truly spearhead revivals are not able to live on what the church would give them. Sadly, the church is still made up of relatively carnal people who do not suffer thinking about lost souls or the honor of Jesus Christ. In our day, Christians are inclined to support ministries which excel in "packaging" a Christian product/image far more than apostolic leaders who put their lives on the line to rip open Satan's kingdom and set the captives free. Many Christians prefer to give to things related to their own interests - (i.e. to their own church's development and comfort) or to someone who promises that they will benefit materially if they give to them, and has the glossy brochures and expensive books and tapes to prove it. It has been proven that the Body of Christ is currently guided more by glossy packaging and clever copy writers than by the Holy Spirit in their giving. Many large ministries employ non-christian marketers to write copy for their begging letters, because they know how to use psychology to bring in the bucks, even if they don't believe a word of it themselves.

However, I believe though as time goes on and the church matures we will be looking out for people to support who are genuinely putting their lives on the line for the Lord, whose ministry results in the formation of new and vibrant churches, whose messages and prayers shake the portals of hell. When I go to developing nations these are the people I am looking to help. I know what it is like to be out there on the front lines of evangelism in desperate need, while desiring perhaps even the crumbs that fall from the tables of well-packaged teaching ministries. That is why I like now to use the money I earn to give to people who are involved in genuine and not merely administrative apostolic function. I believe many others would feel this way if they went and got involved in church planting as I have done. It changes your perspective on things.

False Apostles and How to Recognise them
Paul had to deal with the problem of false apostles. After Paul's departure, the Corinthian church had been infiltrated by false apostles who claimed to be better than Paul. These men claimed to be so good and so worthy, that unlike Paul, they required financial reward for their ministries. While Paul was meek and humble, these men seemed so powerful. They had the corporate CEO empire building attitude. They knew how to slap the believers into line. As Paul wrote: "For you put up with it if one brings you into bondage, if one devours you, if one takes from you, if one exalts himself, if one strikes you on the face. To our shame I say that we were too weak for that!" (2 Corinthians 11:20,21). Here we see some of the marks of false apostles.

They bring people into bondage. True apostolic ministry liberates people to be all they can be in Christ, but false apostles bring people into bondage. True apostles want to present the church perfect, fully equipped, and fruitful in Christ. False apostles just want their ego needs to be met by the church. So they set standards which originate in their own thinking or worse yet in demonic deception, and impose these standards on believers as conditions of belonging. In Paul's day, some of the false apostles claimed to be sent by God and by the church in Jerusalem, but insisted on physical circumcision as a condition for salvation. Going on from there, they would emphasise things like special days to be observed, new moons, feasts, food laws and other such things. Adding law to law, they could get believers to a point where they felt so guilty, so unworthy and therefore so much more in need of the "great men" who could tell them what they had come to believe was the "narrow way" that leads to life. Rules were added, "do not touch, do not taste, do not handle". In reality, it got down to so much ritual, and not a real dealing with the fleshly carnal nature, which is what is at work opposing the work of the Holy Spirit in our lives.

True apostles emphasise first and foremost obedience to the Holy Spirit, but false apostles tend to lay a lot of emphasis on people submitting to and obeying THEM. Now it is right to obey and respect church leaders set by God in authority, but church leaders must lead in the fear of God, and avoid a controlling spirit. False apostles may claim many revelations but these revelations do not set people free to rejoice in the Lord, but rather produce fear and bondage. "Revelations" such as "you must not eat pork" or "you must meet on the Sabbath" or the thousands of strange and bizarre unbiblical rules that some have accepted in the name of religion do not produce freedom, but rather, fear and bondage.

The word of false apostles becomes law to the poor believers who are enslaved by them. Such false apostles will introduce legalistic requirements outside of the Scriptures, and demand adherence. If not, well, its "my way or the highway!". They tend to exclude people who do not bow and scrape to them, so that these people may be powerfully pressured to come into line, so that they can enjoy the acceptance of their friends in the church. In extreme cases, false apostles will claim that they and their group alone are the true heirs of the biblical covenants, so that all those who do not submit to their judgments are ipso facto "outside of Christ", "lost". Both Mormons and Jehovah's witnesses (so-called) are examples of this kind of dangerous nonsense.

They exalt themselves. Anyone who attempts to step into the office of an apostle through self-will, ambitious striving or clever politicking is in line to become a false apostle. Such a person "transforms himself into a minister of righteousness". "For such are false apostles, deceitful workers, transforming themselves into apostles of Christ".

A person may be a Christian, and very talented and impressive outwardly, but if they yield to the sin of pride and start to position themselves in order to draw disciples after themselves, they become false. Sometimes it seems we have a mixture of the true and the false in the same person. It is best to stay within the calling or office that really came from the Lord, and not strive for great titles or recognition. William Branham, a great prophetic ministry of the '50s and '60s, became a false teacher because he insisted on getting outside of his area of calling and function as a Teacher. He just wanted to be a teacher, even though his doctrine was really off the wall. He would not listen to associates and ministers who knew it was wrong. We become false when we seek to appoint ourselves to roles that neither Jesus nor the Spirit of Truth have assigned us.

They Take from You

I don't believe for a moment that these false apostles to which Paul referred would literally break into people's houses and rob them. But they used manipulative tactics to get the people to give them money. It amounts to the same thing. Another favorite tactic is to preach servanthood to others in order to get them primariy to serve THE PREACHER. Actually, Christian leaders, not just Christian followers, are called to be the servants of all. We are servants of one another, but only Christ is the master. It is wonderful when you see a man of God who looks for ways to humbly serve in whatever context he may be found. This is the way Jesus taught us to treat each other when He gave us that great example of washing the disciples' feet (John 13). This was not meant to be merely an additional ritual to be performed after the Lord's supper celebration, as wonderful as that may be, but an exhortation to take a completely different attitude than the leaders of this world, who focus mainly on what will benefit them and their own vision, rather than helping people for the sake of Christ. In Matthew 25, Jesus identified with the hungry, the naked, the sick and the ones in prison, and not with the pastors and church leaders. That is interesting. He did not include pastors in that list. The emphasis is not always shared today by pentecostal church leaders. When we serve needy Christians, that is when we are serving Christ the most. When we serve the powerful in order to advance in the hierarchy, we are still serving our own ambitions.

They Strike you on the Face

It is shameful how much hurt has been caused by abusive Christian leaders and false apostles. As leaders, we are called to be gentle among the believers, as a nursing mother. We are not called to whip the people into submission, by spiritual or emotional tactics of domination, with punishments and rewards.

They boast of being Apostles

"But what I do, I will continue to do, that I may cut off the opportunity from those who desire an opportunity to be regarded just as we are in the things of which they boast. For such are false apostles..." (2 Corinthians 11:12,13).

False apostles will boast of things so that they may be regarded as being apostles (as Paul truly was). Just because someone says they are an apostle does not make them false (Paul said plainly he was an apostle), but there is a false boasting which is common to those who want to be regarded as apostles and simply don't resemble or demonstrate Christ as a true apostle does.

There's quite a lot of glamor in the ministry and nowhere is this more exaggerated than in the United States of America. Someone who truly loves the Lord will not revel in the glory and praises of men, but will seek to shed that glory and get on with the business of glorifying God and taking ground from the devil.

False Boasts of Church Planting

One of the psedo-apostolic things that goes on in the world today is when men claim to have planted churches by finding a group of Christians that someone else has labored to bring to Christ, and then putting their "apostolic" stamp on it and declaring it a church planted by themselves. It seems to be like some kind of board game in which the object is to take money from a missions budget and with it plant as many of the church's flags on foreign works in exchange for the minimum amount of financial support necessary. God save us from this. That may be helping church planters somewhat but it is not "planting the church". Sometimes its hard to know how many churches a person has really planted. There is a big difference between catalysing a church plant through evangelism and a three day seminar, and doing the hard yards month after month on the ground with baby Christians. The latter is not so glamourous, but it has to be done by someone. Both kinds of ministry are of value, but its very important I believe for us to be honest about what we did and not try to impress people in order to gain financial support. "Deceitful workers" is one description of false apostles. I can just imagine the false teachers who came to Corinth and Galatia claiming that they, not Paul, were the true fathers of the church, because of their supposed higher revelations, which were nothing but false and enslaving doctrines.

What True Apostles Need

True apostolic ministry needs above all your prayers. The great apostle Paul constantly asked for prayer support (Colossians 4:2-4 for example). The effectiveness of apostolic ministry depends much on the prayers of sending and supporting churches. Apostles need the saints to fight with them in the spiritual battle for souls and for the maturing of the church. It is a constant and often bitter struggle with many opposing forces. Look around your movement and beyond for missionaries and church planters who are doing this kind of work. Whether they are "apostles" or not in the fullest sense of the word is not the issue. Pray for them, that the Lord may give them strength, utterance courage and love.

True apostolic ministry needs times of fellowship. When church planters return to the home church, seek them out and arrange times of sharing with them. The churches in Antioch and Jerusalem listened eagerly to Paul relate how God worked through him and his team with mighty signs and wonders and in bringing people to Christ. There should be a giving and receiving of love. The apostle John praised his friend Gaius who was always looking out to bless travelling apostles and evangelists who were on the Lord's business (see 3 John 2).

This article will be updated in the future, by the grace of God. I hope you have found it helpful in its present form.
Michael Fackerell

see above



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 10/29/2008 12:40PM by TurningPointReject.