Quote
orylee
I don't expect you to gain anything from it VTV. If you could, you would've already done so. I'm not here to argue with you. We will have to earn the dissociation of cult label with our organization.
Nobody with any credibility has ever called us a "cult". I didn't ask you what you thought
I expected to gain from it. I asked you what you thought you were going to gain from it.
Quote
Eric Monsetti
Enough with the hand waving, that is probably not what is really going on, VTV. Your words tell me you don't understand what I said in those discussions, which is why I ultimately had to bring them here. You treated me like dirt for disagreeing with you about something that you still don't seem to quite grasp.
I understood just fine. I also investigated the situation for myself. And it was as I suspected. You were abusive in your tone during a meeting and had a habit of behaving that way. So like other people who have behaved like trolls in the movement you were eventually banned just like people ban people from the communications mediums of organizations all the time. I read the chat logs, and listened to the meeting recording.
Quote
Eric Monsetti
I don't understand your semantics, "Thanks for re-posting most of the argument people gave to you when this came up then. Not sure what you hoped to accomplish by re-posting it here?". If you don't comprehend, then why are you thanking me? I'm pretty sure most people here are now bored and don't care. Do what you want. Mainly I'm here to discuss the words shared between me and VTV in the conversation, but I didn't want to take them out of their contexts, which seems to help from my point of view.
Then contact me on Facebook. This is not relevant to the conversation here. (I doubt you will do that. Trolls generally want an audience.)
Quote
Eric Monsetti
Veneration and devotion for the "Resource Based Economy" , "Peter Joseph" and the top tier "Coordinators" could be included, as promulgated by the founder of TZM and the very few national/international coordinators. Even if there is no direct stated veneration qualifying it to be a cult, TZM still demonstrates that it exhibits characteristics/signs that it is an unsafe group.
It exhibits what signs that it is an unsafe group? Again this is what annoyed me about you in the first place when you suggested you being removed from a coordinator position for being disruptive and abusive to members of the organization makes the organization "cult like". What "unsafe" activities? You were attending Team speak meetings and then were told you were not welcome at online meetings anymore. Nobody came to your house and threatened you. Nobody poisoned your children. Nobody sexually abused you. This is why your suggestion is so asinine. There is no "cult abuse" going on. Judging by your behavior your just another troll with a grudge.
Quote
Eric Monsetti
Also the coordinator structure is designed to give more power to the higher tiers and less power to the lower tiers. Hence, a national coordinator can remove a State coordinator from communication mediums without any discourse from other State Coordinators that are relevant to the decision.
Sort of. You have to do something to warrant it. And you did. The hierarchy you describe is used in businesses, non-profits, activist organizations, political campaigns, etc.
Quote
Eric Monsetti
It's still in progress, but my idea to improve TZM would be to change the coordinator structure from this,
International— [Countries]
State/Province— [ Next lower degree regional distinctions within a given Country ]
City/Town— [ Next lower degree regional distinctions within a given State or Province ]
Into this,
International/State/Province/City/Town
There would be no "lower". I would simply make a distinction between regional location, plus no person can occupy the entire country all at once, so should never be considered capable of being responsible for all that. Whoever wants to be listed under any regional level, should be able to make it so themselves. The terms higher and lower implies a pyramidal structure. All coordinators do the same type of things, so could easily work without any leaders of the coordinators. Coordinators aren't even leaders of non-coordinators in their respective chapters, but information relays to help realize organized action on the local levels.
This would flatten the hierarchy, where as long as privileges are not exclusive to any person due to their title, there would effectively be no structural or inherent centralization or 'inverted T' with regards to decision making, hence more compatible with the ideals of our organization. It already self-organizes itself this way, as the people at the highest levels are still heavily influenced by their grassroots chapter proximity. This can be problematic when they inherit more power, and thus have more influence spilling over in the entire global movement. I witness this taking place. The US chapter is centralized around the State Chapter in California, as that is now where the International Coordinator for United States(JenWilding) and Founder(PeterJoseph) both live and organize local events, and feed off each others inherited power. This can very well change, though. This could apply to the whole world, not just the US.
So you have problems with the way the organization administrates itself. I get that. None of what you described above makes anything a cult.
There is also the issue of what power do people in the "hierarchy" even have? Coordinators organize meetings. Send out newsletters. Etc. There is no "power" they wield that can in any way harm anyone. This is further why this is so silly.
Quote
Eric MonsettiNational coordinators not answering to anyone other than themselves, and not following the
TZM Structure. Making unilateral decisions on behalf of other chapters, overruling sub-coordinator (the structural existence of sub-coordinators that answer to higher ranking coordinators also is of a concern) concerns without rational consensus. It is hierarchy as it is absent rational consensus when warranted as spelled out in TZM Structure. The guidelines don't apply to the people who are in the most critical positions.
So lets say for a moment that all of your allegations in this quote are correct. SO WHAT? You are quoting stuff from Rick Ross's cult guidelines and the sort of things he is worried about is people in a hierarchy handing out mass suicide orders. That's why the distinction you are trying to make is so disgusting. So if there is a hierarchy in the organization (You know, like virtually all organizations on planet earth that are not cults.) again, what is the big deal? Why does this warrant you throwing out the word "cult" and abusing the term to try and get attention for yourself?
Quote
Eric Monsetti
“No tolerance for questions or critical enquiry. “
National level coordinator holding my criticism, against me to justify decisions as to whether I am an official coordinator loyal to TZM. So making the personal decision to revoke my privileges that served a function for my chapter's operations.
No, you are leaving out the fact that what was not tolerated was you personally attacking people in chat and going out of your way to be disruptive. I question and critically inquire all the time. It's the manner in which you do so that matters. No organization would put up with the way you were acting. Nor should they. And again, lets look at what we are talking about here. You were removed as a coordinator which means:
1. You don't have access to any mass email functions of chapter websites.
2. You are not the contact point for activists within the organization in your area anymore.
...so? Where is the evil cult abuse? Are members of the Zeitgeist Movement stalking you like Scientology members? Are you receiving harassing emails and phone calls? Have you been threatened? Is anyone trying to coerce you to come back? Are there cars with strange armed men outside your house like Katie Holmes?
No. And the reality is if you were not still conducting this campaign you would likely never hear from anyone in TZM again. No harm was done to you.
Quote
Eric Monsetti
“Unreasonable fear about the outside world, such as impending catastrophe, evil conspiracies and persecutions. “
Peter Joseph not disclosing who he really is, out of paranoia that he and his so called ordinary helpless family will be killed or something, and asking/allowing other members to disclose who they really are, as compared to the Anonymous organization. Also Pj making stuff up about his life for perhaps the purposes to improve his image. Again, TZM is not alone, and TVP does really share this warning sign to a degree.
Eric, as I pointed out to you earlier and you continue to ignore. Filmmakers, Authors, Actors, etc all sometimes use different versions of their names. Peter has received death threats. Just like many other authors, filmmakers, actors, etc. His family has also been targeted for harassment. That's reality. It's not unreasonable paranoia. The California and the New York Chapters have both met him. When he is at events it's easy to meet and talk to him. You COMPLETELY took what this "warning sign" is all about out of context to suit your own purposes.
Hell, just the bullshit you see on Kush and Mario's blogs is proof positive of harassment and demonstrates why people have to be careful about using their real names for public endeavors sometimes. My use of my real name has handed them keys to put my personal life in the spotlight. They have taken private photos of myself, my family and my friends and attached them to false articles that are now part of my google index when people search my name. That can affect things like how easily you can get a job. I have also NEVER seen Peter ask anyone or expect anyone to use their names.
Quote
Eric Monsetti
There’s just a lot of things that have never been verified and may negatively impact other members/activists when a time comes when it is forcibly revealed by people who know what they are doing. There are also many people who are not going by aliases, including almost all the rest of the TZM support base. . We can’t have a real conversation until we get confirmation from him or a 3rd party to determine why he truly does obscure his name. I already have hypotheses that seem very valid to me, and if he had gone the more truthful route, it would sully the image of TZM, not put him in mortal danger.
I have already covered most of this. But the idea you suggest "has never been verified" is nonsense. Peter is not asking for large sums of money from anyone. Does not demand "membership dues" and generally pays for most of his activism out of his own pocket and at personal financial risk.
Quote
Eric Monsetti
“Former members often relate the same stories of abuse and reflect a similar pattern of grievances. “
There are others who have been wronged in similar ways to me. There are actually videos concerning Jen Wilding’s lack of accountability on youtube from previous State coordinators. Not saying I share all the same views and opinions as the so called ‘trolls’.
Sigh....
Eric, ABUSE and GRIEVANCES include physical abuse, mental abuse, sexual abuse, financial exploitation, people ACTUALLY GETTING HURT. Not people being removed from coordinator positions and removed from mass email lists. Seriously man.
Quote
Eric Monsetti
She [Jen Wilding the sole national coordinator] seems to be making unilateral decisions
Ok, lets pause there for a moment. Making unilateral decisions
about what? If you are going to wave the cult label around, lets ask a few questions. Is anyone telling you they are going to have sex with your wife? Is anyone telling you they are going to have sex with your daughter? Is anyone telling you that you are going to have to committ suicide to achieve salvation? Is anyone beating you or threatening you?
No. You got removed from a coordinator position due to your conduct. No more. No less. The ACTUAL victims of cults have REAL stories of abuse.
Quote
Eric Monsetti
I was banned for some technical reason (a recent small disagreement that I can barely remember on US chapter meetings + joking around with some people on TS, where others got the wrong idea about what I said in the context–ie me typing “i’m gonna kill all of you” taken out of its context and taken literally) that I have completely debunked already, and she refuses to recognize it. As she is the sole national coordinator of the entire USA, this puts me in bad standing with TZM-US, even though my own chapter definitely thinks otherwise, as they have already put me up again as the St.Charles coordinator. She had taken me off my chapter’s website without consulting with anybody.Even the person (and the moderator who was contacted by that person) who reported me on TeamSpeak said they felt bad for reporting me (i made a bad joke that this person didn’t catch, probably in part due to I didn’t vocalize it and they didn’t get my tone or were not following the conversation going on)..
Again Eric, you are just not being honest. You were not joking. You were politely asked to stop. You kept going. And again. You don't have anything here that represents cult abuse.
Quote
Eric Monsetti
I can also go into who I think Peter Joseph really is, but I'm not saying I am 100% certain of my theory, and would not want you to be either.
...and? Again. So what? If he is trying to be super mysterious man he is doing a poor job by doing things like appearing on Russia Today, posting videos of himself to millions of viewers on youtube, etc.
Eric, if you actually cared about TZM, you would not be doing any of this. This is obviously about you.