It seems that it is appropriate now to bring up the personal attack on my person from one member of the Gnostic Movement that was carried out in the general Samael Aun Weor discussion board. [
forum.culteducation.com]. I just realized that it seems I have not fully brought this up before. Here it is and I will write some more on it shortly.
Hi Jeff (notanantiGnostic),
In my opinion, it is not right to spread lies about someone, a group of people, or an organisation. The Gnostic Movement is an open and democratic organisation.
The quote that I think you are talking about, which is in the book Secret Knowledge, Hidden Wisdom (which is for sale to the public at www.absolutepublishingpress.com), is misrepresented. I will post it here:
----------------------------------------------------------------
Q: I have been debating with the issue of whether or not joining the military is a proper decision in consistency with the teachings of modern Gnosis. My hunch is that it is not. On the one hand people tell me, and I used to believe, that violence is wrong but self-defence is not. But then I remember that Jesus advocated extreme non-violence, and when I think about this, it makes much sense to me, and I like that.
But mainly my father is telling me that it is a selfish way of looking at the world, because if I allow myself to be killed in the name of faith, I still leave my family behind to suffer. That is where my main conflict is. What would the teachings of modern Gnosis guide me to do in this situation?
A: A country needs to have military forces to defend itself in case anyone attacks it. If you don't defend yourself, you will allow evil to prevail. Would you let an idiot kill your familiy if you were able to stop him, even if it meant killing him? If you didn't do that, you would get karma for not defending what you should have. The person who does those evil things is no better than a demon.
But the country or person needs to make sure that they do not cause the attack on themselves in the first place.
Q: If one chooses to join the military and truly believes in their heart of hearts that what they are doing is defence, then they are doing the right thing, correct? Well what if they are just a victim of propaganda, and do not realize that it was their country that initiated a war?
A: If there is a choice in joining the military, then someone who wants to take up the path would have to look into whehter joining the military would allow them the time and opportunities that they need to be able to help other people with their spiritual progress.
They also have to look into what was expected of them when joining and what the government is doing. Bear in mind too that it puts you in physical danger; you need to see whether the cause justifies the risk, becuase the body is needed for this work - that's why we are here. Different countries get up to different things - being a pawn for a corrupt government is not recommended.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Here the author, Belzebuub answers to a specific question about joining the military. I happen to agree with what he says there and I think most people would. You are giving people the wrong impression and view of what he says, which is not right, obviously trying to discredit him unjustly by taking things out of context and misrepresenting them. It is obviously anyone's right to voice their opinions, but quite another to openly and unjusly slander someone - this shows no respect for others, nor common decency.
On this forum, you are using people’s concerns to get them against someone who is perfectly innocent. Also, you are trying to harm an individual and an organisation just because you have a distorted view of them. I am sure that the purpose of this forum is not to provide an avenue for unjustified slander and lies against an individual or an organisation.
You attended one of the The Gnostic Movement's Centres and you also left it of your own volition; we haven't tried to keep you or anything like that as you have hinted in many of your posts here. In fact, we were very accomodating with you and tried to help as best as we could, even with your condition of having been depressed in the past and diagnosed with ADD. We had also attended to your request to run a particular course just for you when you asked us to. Just to mention another of many things, we gave you numerous lifts home from there as friends. We find it strange that here you are today vehemently attacking us and the author of the books that you decided to read and try to practise what was in them, just because you no longer agree with what we do and have stopped attending.
This whole thing is puzzling, food for thought.
I have decided to participate in this forum now to put things into context, because many people could become victims of your own misinterpretations and misconceptions, which wouldn't be fair to them.
Jordan