Another article appearing in Medical Observer published 30th of July.
If you think that medical practice should be based on evidence and aimed at prevention, diagnosis, treatment and cure, then you will probably find it interesting. Same goes if you think healthcare advice should be provided by government accredited, qualified and regulated professionals. And if you agree that companies should be made accountable that create products and make therapeutic claims that haven't been evaluated by the government body responsible for administering such products then read on. If however you live in some fantasy land where your health is managed by an unqualified magic man who people should believe because he says so, then this is probably not for you, put your Chris James headphones on, sit on your postcard and channel your master, secure in your knowledge that Big Daddy Serge will tuck you in at night and make the bad men of truth and evidence go away.
Full article below as available for members of the Medical Observer readership of 28,000 health professionals at the following link: [
www.medicalobserver.com.au]
Concerns raised over 'prana' treatment - Medical Observer
MORE questions have been raised about treatments being offered by the Universal Medicine (UM) organisation in northern NSW following revelations a man, with what appeared to be a potentially life-threatening condition, was told by the founder of UM that “this is you releasing the evil/prana… from your body”.
As first reported in MO, northern NSW-based UM is the subject of multiple HCCC complaints involving allegations it is a “cult” that encourages its estimated 400 followers into avoiding most food, exercise and traditional medicine.
Herbal products sold by the group are meanwhile subject to a TGA investigation, with the TGA stating that Universal was selling unregistered alternative treatments in dosage packs, which “therefore meet the definition of therapeutic goods as they make general therapeutic claims for use in humans”.
MO has obtained a newsletter circulated to Universal’s students in which Queensland naturopath Steffen Messerschmidt is pictured with severe swelling and redness in his hands, arms and face. His written account in the newsletter says the symptoms presented in December 2008, after he had demonstrated “Dorn” spinal therapy on UM's founder Serge Benhayon.
Mr Messerschmidt wrote in the newsletter that Mr Benhayon told him “this is you releasing the evil/prana of Dorn Therapy from your body – a little more to go”, and to take photos of the swelling, and that Mr Benhayon said “sorry to hear this is still happening but I can’t help being excited by [it]”.
Dr Michael Vagg from Deakin University School of Medicine said the pictures “clearly indicate a potentially serious condition that I would say requires an urgent referral to a rheumatologist or haematologist for diagnosis”.
"It could be some type of urticarial vasculitis or autoimmune condition like lupus," Dr Vagg told MO.
“It would seem the patient has been quite lucky to survive as the facial swelling is an obvious sign of potential impending airway obstruction. With a condition such as this there is also the risk of major organ failure – particularly kidney failure."
Mr Messerschmidt said aside from Mr Benhayon, he showed his condition to “GPs and specialists” but “there was no reason to explain how that could have happened”.
“My body went through a pretty big shift and I was clearing lots and lots of things, like the pictures that you saw,” he said.
“Scientifically you can’t explain why I came up with third degree burns in the hands.”
Mr Benhayon told MO his remarks to Mr Messerschmidt were “a light-hearted quip… based on many months of discussion”.
“I saw only an emailed pic of a swollen hand,” he said. “In that quip, what I say is true according to the way I know and understand energy. But under no circumstance was it a diagnosis. Steffen never asked nor did I offer. When I did see him next… I firmly recommended he see a GP.”
Mr Benhayon added that Mr Messerschmidt “never once approached me in my capacity as an esoteric practitioner in regards to those conditions”.
“He chose to deal with his ill condition as he is qualified to do. He has a naturopathic degree from Germany which he tells me is medically high in standard," he said.
Professor John Dwyer, from Friends of Science in Medicine, said organisations like Universal that “take money in return for offering medical services when they have neither training nor credibility, but are willing to hoodwink the public into thinking that they have some mystical way of curing disease, even serious disease, are a public health menace”.
Please feel free to discuss this article below.